Challenge for German left

Submitted by AWL on 4 October, 2005 - 6:57

Germany's new left party, Die Linke.PDS, will be the largest left opposition in Parliament to a probable "grand coalition" government of the Social Democratic Party (SPD) and the main right-wing opposition, the CDU/CSU.

In the country's 18 September general election, the SPD got 222 seats, the CDU/CSU 226. The press speculates that the "grand coalition" which they are likely to be form will not be able to carry through the hard-edged Thatcherite programme that CDU leader Angela Merkel offered in the election. But it may. In any case, it will certainly carry on the more gradual neo-liberal policy initiated by the SPD-Green government with its "Hartz IV" plan.

Die Linke.PDS's 8.7% on 18 September certainly reflects some substantial left-wing sentiment. The main planks of Die Linke.PDS's election platform included: work for all; renew and guarantee social provision; more direct democracy; a renewed European Union...

Die Linke.PDS's best-known leader, the former leading SPD politician Oskar Lafontaine, has made nationalist speeches, but the party's election platform said: "Germany is a country of immigration... Foreigners should no longer be alien".

According to Die Linke.PDS, a lot of their voters are young. An opinion survey across Germany in April found only one quarter of the population had "a good opinion" of capitalism, and 45% had "no good opinion" of it.

But Lafontaine is certainly no working-class socialist; and Die Linke.PDS's other leader, Gregor Gysi, comes from the former ruling party of East Germany, the SED. The question is, how much potential is there within Die Linke.PDS to group together a working-class political force independent of Lafontaine and Gysi?

Most of the groups of the German would-be Marxist left - Linksruck (linked to the SWP), SAV (linked to the Socialist Party), and the ISL (linked to Socialist Resistance) - have enthusiastically jumped into Die Linke.PDS. RSB/Avanti (also linked to Socialist Resistance) remains outside, and some would-be Marxists remain as oppositionists in the SPD.

But the SPD still has over 500,000 members. Die Linke.PDS was formed in July 2005 by the coming-together of the PDS (the reconstructed remnant of the old SED), Lafontaine, and WASG, a splinter from the SPD led by officials in the IG Metall trade union. It has 62,000 members, of whom 5,000 are in West Germany. The five thousand West German members, and maybe a section of the East German members, must surely be people whom Marxists must reach. How far they can get within Die Linke.PDS remains to be seen, because there is huge deadweight.

Die Linke.PDS is still mainly Eastern-based. It got over 20% of the vote on 18 September in most parts of East Germany, but under 5% in most of the West outside Lafontaine's bastion in the Saar (www.euroneuzeit.de/blog/?p=881).

The 57,000 East German members are mostly ex-SED, and two-thirds of them are over 60 years old. The PDS is in the state (provincial) governments in Berlin and Mecklenburg Vorpommern, and has carried through policies there no different from the SPD.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 05/10/2005 - 12:25

- the linkspartei had also some good results above 5% in some western german regions and cities like hamburg, bremen, oberhausen, duisburg, etc.
- lafontaine (who is not as mad as galloway (who can better be compared with the late juergen moellemann) but this does not mean, that he is good) supports also the legilization of torture under certain conditions
- a good article from the viewpoint of the rsb: http://www.internationalviewpoint.org/article.php3?id_article=866

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 07/10/2005 - 11:37

I think you are probably wrong about the Linke.PDS party beingthe palce where MArxists should work. Just look atthe demographics and ask yourselves who these people were. Not the working class for sure but the old ruling party of the bureaucratic absolutist state in East Germany. And most of them will be deid soon. good job too - parasites! In fact here is no good place for marxists/socialists. The SPD and the Greens must still also be palces to work dependeing on local conditions and the various campaigns. The other problem is still what left, which party or groupuscle. you know we need a new formaulation of marxism for our time on a grand scale that can blow away the pretenders. But that doesn't really seem possible.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 07/10/2005 - 14:05

In reply to by Anonymous (not verified)

its true, that important part of the membership of the linkspartei are former state-/party bureaucrats (east) and trade union bureaucrats (west) ... but why working inside bourgeois neoliberal parties like the spd or greens? nearly no sane leftist in germany remains in them. the most important task now is the activity in the extra-parliamentary field, like in unions, community groups, etc. not in parties whose orientation is mainly parliamentarian

This website uses cookies, you can find out more and set your preferences here.
By continuing to use this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.